Waterfront Algoma Vacation Rental on Lake Michigan

Property ID: 491171AlgomaWIUS
Sleeps 42 BR1 BA
Book with confidence

Most trips qualify for free 48 hour cancellation. Add dates for more information.


Boating, fishing, hunting, and endless lakefront adventures await upon booking this 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom vacation rental on the shore of Lake Michigan! This charming Algoma, WI, home features a comfortable open living space, a well-equipped kitchen, and large picture windows that overlook the gorgeous waters. Spend your days enjoying the surrounding marinas, beaches, and golf courses before heading back to grill out on the private patio and dine under the stars at the 'Serenity Shore' getaway.


  • Wireless Internet (WIFI)
  • Central Heating
  • Kitchen
  • Waterfront
  • Free Parking
  • Self Check-In


Location Details

SEE + DO: Crescent Beach Boardwalk (3 miles), von Stiehl Winery (3 miles), Algoma Pierhead Lighthouse (3 miles), Ahnapee Brewery (3 miles), Door County Peninsula (19 miles), Door 44 Winery (26 miles), Lambeau Field (38 miles), NEW Zoo & Adventure Park (41 miles)

OUTDOOR ATTRACTIONS: Alaskan Golf Club (3 miles), Blahnik Heritage Park (6 miles), CD Buzz Besadny State Fish and Wildlife Area (12 miles), Little Scarboro State Public Hunting Grounds (13 miles), 27 Pines Golf Course (18 miles), Idlewild Golf Club (23 miles), Bay Beach Mini Golf (29 miles)

ON THE WATER: Wayside Park (0.4 miles), Haasch Guide Service Inc. (3 miles), Captain K’s Landing (3 miles), City of Algoma Marina (3 miles), East Alaska Lake (4 miles), Door County Boat Rental (21 miles), South Bay Marina & Marine Center (30 miles)

AIRPORT: Green Bay Austin Straubel International Airport (41 miles)


22 reviews
  • Weekend Girls Trip


    Absolutely adored this property! It was so relaxing to have all the windows open and enjoy the sounds of the lake. Perfect location for people wanting to stay out of the congestion in Door County. We really enjoyed spending time on the back patio watching the water and taking in the serenity. We would definitely stay here again! Thank you!

    *This review was originally posted on Vrbo

    Published July 7, 2024
  • Quiet and quaint... a perfect Lake Michigan getaway


    This property and the overall experience ... truly incredible. The pictures are spot-on for this property. Gorgeous, clean home with amazing views. The property was very well-appointed with everything you'd need, and the welcome notes and tourism materials were so appreciated. The remodel of this quaint property was exceptionally well-done, with attention to retaining the character of the original home.

    If you aren't a huge fan of the "touristy" aspect of vacations and are looking for a slower, quieter locale, definitely consider staying in the southern part of the peninsula where this property is located. You can drive north an hour or so to visit those towns to enjoy the shopping and restaurants there, and then escape back south to the solitude of this amazing property. Businesses and restaurants in Algoma and Kewaunee alone can fill your time and interest.

    Just be prepared... you might not be able to stay awake if you rest and relax in the back yard. The repetitive sound of waves crashing on the rocks below is hypnotic and lovely.

    A perfect getaway. Thank you!

    *This review was originally posted on Vrbo

    Published July 3, 2024
    Manager's Response:

    From the owner: "Hi Beth, we are so glad you chose Serenity Shore for a get-a-way! The Southern Peninsula does have a tremendous amount to offer. Your kind words regarding the house and the property are appreciated. We get great satisfaction from sharing the beauty of the lake with others and are happy you enjoyed your stay! Thank You!"

  • 5/5

    Beautiful property with breathtaking view of the lake! Close proximity to towns like Sturgeon Bay with dining/shopping. Our stay was wonderful!

    *This review was originally posted on Vrbo

    Published June 16, 2024
    Manager's Response:

    From the owner: "Martin, thank you for staying at Serenity Shore. we are glad you enjoyed your visit! The view of Lake Michigan is an always changing wonder.
    Thank you!"

  • Family vaca


    The house was perfect and had everything we needed for our stay. The location was the reason we picked this house and it did not disappoint, the view was Beautiful!!

    *This review was originally posted on Vrbo

    Published June 14, 2024
    Manager's Response:

    From the owner: "Hi Elizabeth, family vacations are important times in our lives and we are thrilled that you chose Serenity Shore to stay at! Thank you and we hope to see you back again."

  • Very nice place


    We enjoyed our mother/daughter getaway at your lovely home. The views of the water are amazing! Very close to upper Door County.

    *This review was originally posted on Vrbo

    Published March 29, 2024
    Manager's Response:

    From the owner: ''Hi Christine, We are thrilled you chose Serenity Shore for a mother-and-daughter getaway! The beauty of Lake Michigan is amazing! We are glad you stayed and hope to see you back soon!''

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Still have questions?

Reach out help with general questions about the property.

Private homes with hospitality

We promise private, professionally-cleaned vacation rentals with 24/7 guest support so you can travel without worry.
Best Rate

Best Rate

You’re guaranteed to book the best rates on our vacation homes at

Rest Easy

Rest Easy

If plans change or the vacation rental isn’t what we promised, we’re here to help make it right.

Icon showing an outstretched hand holding a heart icon

Give Back

Bookings on support our Building Hospitality program.

Add dates for prices
22 reviews

Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Select Guests
  • This property has a maximum occupancy of 4 guests, not including infants.
  • Pets are not allowed at this property.
Ages 2-12