Apartment
5

Lisle Apt: Fireplace & Stained Glass Windows!

Property ID: 458744LisleNYUS
Sleeps 63 BR1 BA

Description

Visit Lisle in style by staying at a renovated church! Boasting a spacious open floor plan, tall ceilings, and stained glass windows, this apartment offers decadence in its architecture and uniqueness in its history. Choose this 2-bedroom, 1-bath vacation rental and be an easy drive to Binghamton, the carousel capital of the world! Try Dorchester Park for kayaking, fishing, nature walks, the nearby Finger Lakes for water sports and stunning waterfalls, or explore Ithaca for shopping and dining.

Amenities

  • Kitchen
  • Free Parking
  • Deck
  • Wireless Internet (WIFI)
  • Washer
  • Essentials
  • Central Heating
  • Self Check-In

Map

Location Details

FINGER LAKES: Cayuga Lake (30.1 miles), Owasco Lake (44.5 miles), Seneca Lakes (51.0 miles)

OUTDOOR ADVENTURES: Lisle Village Pool (seasonal) (0.3 miles), Dorchester Park (4.7 miles), Whitney Point Multiple Use Area (7.0 miles), Greenwood Park (9.4 miles), Robinson Hollow State Forest (16.3 miles), Shindagin Hollow State Forest (21.4 miles)

LOCAL HOT SPOTS: French Distillers & Alchemists, LLC (358 feet), Ford Hill Country Club (restaurant on-site) (3.1 miles), Thunder Mountain Speedway (4.0 miles), Greek Peak Mountain Resort (skiing, tubing & dining) (15.5 miles), Binghamton (20.3 miles)

ITHACA: Cornell University (27.3 miles), Ithaca Commons (shopping) (28.0 miles), Ithaca College (28.1 miles), State Theatre of Ithaca (28.3 miles), Cornell Botanic Gardens (28.3 miles), Buttermilk Falls State Park (28.5 miles), Robert H. Treman State Park (32.5 miles)

AIRPORT: Greater Binghamton Airport (13.1 miles)

Reviews

5
21 reviews
  • 5/5

    One the most unique and beautiful places I've ever stayed in. It's in a great location for skiing at Greek Peak and visiting Ithaca, Binghamton, and Cortland.

    *This review was originally posted on Vrbo

    Nathan
    Published February 8, 2026
    Manager's Response:

    Thank you Nathan! So appreciate you input and you taking the time to review.

  • 5/5

    Excellent!

    *This review was originally posted on Vrbo

    Kelly
    Published December 6, 2025
    Manager's Response:

    We appreciate your review!

  • 5/5

    The stay was as beautiful as the photos and the host was so thoughtful and kind. The details like snacks, a welcome note, and a local guidebook really put the stay over the top. Excellent!

    *This review was originally posted on Vrbo

    Adelaide
    Published October 27, 2025
    Manager's Response:

    So glad it met with your expectations! Thank you for staying at Church Mouse. We appreciate you taking time out to send a review.

  • A wonderfully delightful stay!

    5/5

    My family of six visited from the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia and spent a week here. We had a wonderful experience! Staying in a renovated church sanctuary was quirky and delightful.

    The unit was extremely clean... one of the cleanest we've stayed in. The space was quite comfortable. It was also well-stocked with essentials. We were pleasantly surprised with the snacks and coffee station offered by our hosts.

    For our purposes, the location was convenient to the things that we wanted to do: a day trip to Cooperstown and short excursions to Ithaca and Binghamton.

    No concerns. Highly recommended!

    Derek
    Published August 2, 2025
    Manager's Response:

    We so appreciate your review! As they say , cleanliness is next to Godliness! Thank you for being our guest.

  • 5/5

    I loved the ambiance this place had. The gorgeous church really made us feel love upon seeing the grandeur upon first entering. We continued to love it with the nice air-conditioning, snacks, coffee, and comfortable beds. I love that the integrity of the church had been maintained in the remodeling, too. The porch with lighting was a nice place to sit with our friends in the evening and chat. Parking was a breeze. Our host was easy to contact and cared about us with each contact. I love that we were far enough from Ithaca and Seneca to avoid exorbitant pricing on a stay, yet close enough for multiple trips to see waterfalls, gorges, breweries, and wineries. We definitely want to stay again and bring our other daughter and our son next time as well! Thank you for this opportunity!

    *This review was originally posted on Vrbo

    Melanie
    Published July 27, 2025
    Manager's Response:

    Thank you so much for taking time to leave a review. This church is special to us, we want to preserve the work of those who maintained it so well in the past. We are glad to hear our porch is being used! We'd love to have you come stay again.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Still have questions?

Reach out help with general questions about the property.

We make vacation rental easy

Our modern approach to hospitality and property management puts the focus on five-star stays and owner-centric strategies.
Guests rest easy

Guests rest easy

Count on the best rates, flexible cancellations, and vetted homes

Owners get support

Owners get support

Reach your rental goals with expert guidance and exclusive tools

Everyone benefits

Everyone benefits

Trust our team for excellent service and best-in-class support

Add dates for prices
5
21 reviews

Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Guests
Select Guests
  • This property has a maximum occupancy of 6 guests, not including infants.
  • Pets are not allowed at this property.
Adults
0
Children
Ages 2-12
0
Infants
0