Book with confidence
Most trips qualify for free 48 hour cancellation. Add dates for more information.
Most trips qualify for free 48 hour cancellation. Add dates for more information.
‘Cozy Cottage’ | Dog Friendly w/ Fee | 3-Season Room | Gas Grill | Fire Pit
Make this 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom Monticello vacation rental your next home away from home! This renovated cottage features a cozy living area, a fully equipped kitchen, and a private outdoor space with on-site access to Lake Shafer. Spend your time sipping vino at local wineries, golfing at nearby courses, or floating along the lazy river at Indiana Beach!
- On-site access to Lake Shafer
- Near wineries & breweries
- 2 miles to Tall Timbers Marina
- 5 miles to Indiana Beach Boardwalk Resort
- 35 miles to Lafayette
- 83 miles to South Bend International Airport
Such a great time. Only 10 minutes from Indiana Beach. Loved having morning coffee on the deck every morning. Place was clean and so adorable. We will be back if coming to Indiana again.
*This review was originally posted on Vrbo
From the owner: "Thank you for the fantastic review! We’re happy to hear that your family had a good time at Lake Shafer. Please keep us in mind for your next visit to Indiana!"
My family and I really enjoyed our stay here! We enjoyed the house, it was really like a home away from home. Most definitely enjoyed the private deck over the water. We were fortunate enough to see some of the neighbors doing beautiful fireworks. We were able to bring our dogs, which is a huge plus. We went to Indiana beach one day and the house is so close we were able to come back and cool off a few times! I would definitely recommend staying at this property! It truly met all of our needs.
*This review was originally posted on Vrbo
From the Owner: "Jessica, Thank you so much for the great review! It was a pleasure meeting you and your family, and we're happy you enjoyed your stay. It sounds like you had a great time at Indiana Beach! We look forward to welcoming you back to Lake Shafer."
We booked "Cozy Cottage" for the 5 days over the 4th of July holiday. We had stayed here before and wanted to return. The accommodations were great, the view of the river fabulous and the deck actually sits on the river. 100% great.
*This review was originally posted on Vrbo
From the owner: "Jim, thank you for the fantastic review! It was our pleasure welcoming you back to our cottage. We're happy that you enjoyed your stay and the "float down the Tippecanoe" sounded relaxing. We look forward to seeing you again!"
This was a perfect family getaway! My sister and her husband and my husband and I took a nostalgic trip to Monticello Indiana. Many years ago before retiring we all would spend our weekends on Freeman Lake. This trip took us back to many places along the lake we enjoyed back then.
This was our first time EVER staying in an Airbnb and loved it. We were in the 2 bedroom cabin at Cozy Cottage. Plenty of space for the 4 of us. We especially loved the expansive deck and covered back porch. The accommodations included everything we needed from linens to kitchenware. Tv and Wifi were perfect. We will definitely go there again.
From the Owner: "Patricia, thank you for the great review! Meeting everyone and talking about the "Twin Lakes" was a pleasure. Shafer and Freeman. We're happy that everyone enjoyed the cottage and visiting the area.
We look forward to welcoming you back again!"
Very nice place to stay! Loved the wooden deck over the river.
*This review was originally posted on Vrbo
From the owner: "Thanks for the nice comments! We're happy you enjoyed your stay, keep us in mind for your next visit to Lake Shafer!"
Reach out help with general questions about the property.
Best Rate
You’re guaranteed to book the best rates on our vacation homes at evolve.com.
Rest Easy
If plans change or the vacation rental isn’t what we promised, we’re here to help make it right.
Give Back
Bookings on evolve.com support our Building Hospitality program.